No ill-will meant, only the musically-oriented should sing in films

By O.J.George

At the outset, it should be emphasised that there is no ill-will meant in the suggestion that only the musically-minded should sing in films.

Otherwise, the great mass medium would be hijacked by people of other resources with their music numbers, which would be revolting, when talented singers are available in plenty.

The latest info is that Meera Jasmine is going to sing in a film in which she is acting. Maybe, as demanded by situations, the actors can recite like Dr Ayyappa Panikker, Kadammanitta and the like.

A priest, who is a good church singer, made an anecdote about his visit to a church in America. He was visiting his relatives there and grabbed an opportunity to visit the nearby church on a Sunday hoping that he could join the congregation with his melodious singing. The church remained open on the dot. There were only very few members present for the church service. A very old priest presented himself at the altar, looked at the congregation and announced.”Let us start the service by saying Hymn Number…”.

Considering the poor attendance and dearth of people capable of singing a hymn, the priest most deservedly chose to say a song, rather than indulge in the farce of singing.

When people think about songs, their minds are attuned to Jesudas, Latha Mangeshkar, and the like. Replacing their role with others who are best suited to acting would vitiate creativity.

Music, singing and soporific strains are God-given. Others should not transgress their limits and make their foray into sacred space.

Some may say Mohanlal, Mammootty, Jayaram, Jagadish, Siddique, Innocent, Mala Aravindan, KPAC Lalitha, Kaviyoor Ponnamma, Manju Warrier, Prithviraj have all made their presence felt as singers in films.

But anyone can say they cannot be compared with those who are blessed with music and singing professionally.

Recitation is okay, but let us not burden the audience with cacophony.